The Oystercatcher of Southwark

19th-Century Historical Fiction

The Oystercatcher of Southwark — a novel by Erica Colahan

2025 ACP Excellence in Publishing, 3rd Place
2024 HFC Bronze

Purchase on Amazon

The Story

Philadelphia, 1897 — On the shores of the Delaware River, Italian Catholic Mary Paragano dreams of a happily ever after. However, when she defies her family and runs away to marry Jakob, a Jewish boy, her fairy tale takes an unexpected turn. Disowned by her father, abandoned by Jakob, and pursued by a jealous gangster, Mary's life spirals into tragedy, culminating in accusations of attempting to harm her own children and a harrowing end in an asylum.

Philadelphia, present-day — Bella, Mary's great-great-granddaughter, grapples with the aftermath of her recent divorce. Amidst her pain, a mysterious stranger named Sophie enters her life, claiming to be related to Jakob, the man who left Mary to her devastating fate over a century ago. Together, Bella and Sophie unravel the layers of Mary's haunting past, question the stories they've been told, and uncover the impact of these historical secrets on their modern-day lives.

Based on the remarkable true story of the author's great-great-grandmother, The Oystercatcher of Southwark takes readers on a poignant journey through the immigrant neighborhoods of South Philadelphia. This deftly-woven novel explores the profound love of a mother for her children and the redemptive hope that transcends time.

Inspiration for the Novel

Erica grew up outside Philadelphia hearing rumors that her great-great-grandmother Mary tried to drown her children and then herself in the Delaware River before being committed to an asylum. Captivated, she pictured the scene every time she passed the river.

After years of research, the author has taken the family legend surrounding Mary's tragic life and turned it into a historical fiction full of adventure, engaging characters, and enduring lessons of faith & love.

Historic South Philadelphia neighborhood — inspiration for the novel
Girl holding The Oystercatcher of Southwark — inspired by the real Mary
The real Mary — great-great-grandmother of Author Erica Colahan

Mary

Mary was Author Erica Colahan's great-great-grandmother. Her granddaughter used this photograph to paint two portraits of her. One of these portraits has hung in the family home for more than 100 years.

In addition, the portrait served as inspiration for the striking cover image of The Oystercatcher of Southwark designed by Roseanna M. White, Author, Publisher, and co-owner of Chrism Press, a division of WhiteFire Publishing.

Navigate to Chrism Press

Historical Fiction set in 19th-century Philadelphia

Purchase The Oystercatcher of Southwark

Join the Reader List

Enjoy free short stories, book news & author exclusives.